Thursday, March 09, 2006

Origami Sucks and Microsoft is Doomed

So Microsoft finally unveiled their Origami project today.

Basically it's a big fat heavy PDA, and they seem to think that the fact that it runs a slightly different version of Windows is somehow noteworthy. The 7 ich screen is too big to make it a worthwhile PDA or portable gaming platform (which it most definitely isn't) and too small for people to want to use it to watch movies with. The touch screen interface basically assumes that all people do is poke around the web and click 'next' on their mp3 player program all day. In reality most people spend their time emailing or chattting or blogging or actually working, and using one of those stupid pens or other non-keyboard input devices will cause frustration for anyone wanting to actually do anything useful

Microsoft have once again shown that their only niche is to copy other people's innovations, poorly. In this case they stupidly tried to occupy 3 or 4 different markets with one device, producing something that is mediocre-to-awful for any one of those tasks.

The other problem is that you can't actually go out and buy one of these things now. There isn't even a real "thing" yet, this is just a spec that hardware manufacturers are now expected to implement, just like the 'media centre' idea which has taken off so well. (*cough*). YOu think Microsoft would understand that had they just produced an OS platform and reference spec for a game system, rather than build the X-Box, that it would be a long-dead memory in the minds of the gaming press rather than a major force in the games market.

When apple unveils a product you can go right to the Apple store and order it, even if it isn't shipping yet, there's still an 'it' that people see and can buy. This Origami thing is just too much confusino for most people. The fact that there isn't a manufacturer for the North American market yet doesn't help matters.

What I wanted this thing to be was a 12-14 inch flat screen with a little either fold out or detachable keyboard and a little stand that would let you prop it up and use it like a laptop. With a flash drive or other silent, low-power storage and wireless networking of course. That would be the perfect device for a student to use to take notes in a full day's worth of courses without having to find an electrical outlet after the first two classes drained a typical laptop's batteries, and it would take up less space in a backpack as well.

This thing isn't a threat to either the PSP, the iPod, the Mac Mini or the iBook, and will probably fade away within a couple of months when no hardware maker announces any real products.
Technorati Tags: , , ,

By al - 11:40 a.m. |

Comments:
Interestingly, I was expecting something smaller.

I mean, I'm cynical of media reports but there'd been much talk of it being an 'iPod Killer'. Combined with Steve Jobs perfect comments about Microsoft needing to produce something themselves if they're to challenge the iPod at all, it seemed like perfect timing.

I think tablets have potential. Not as a primary machine, but in addition to existing tools. The screen is probably not bad for portable movie watching, were it not for the terrible battery life rendering that impossible.

Long term, this sort of form factor might have a place. I wouldn't want a tablet too big, anyway. Regardless, this is not the device to do it.

I can't fathom why they've even launched something that's not up to the promise. Apparently the intend is to have a device between 5" and 7" with 'all day' battery life. I can't understand why they'd hurt the concept so much by launching such a terrible first-generation.

I can just feel that Apple are watching and they will wait until people actually want one of these things, just as they've done with Media Centre software and MP3 players. And then they'll make a better one.
 
I just had the thought that maybe a little bluetooth keyboard could go quite a long way to making this into a semi-useful machine, but if the rumoured battery life of 3 hours is true then it really isn't any better than a little laptop.
 
Post a Comment

    follow me on Twitter

    al's del.icio.us Links

    • www.flickr.com
      This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from dragonofsea. Make you own badge here.
    •  
    • (al)



    • Powered by Blogger